What Is the Healthiest Sparkling Water? The Complete Guide to Bubbling Beverages

What Is the Healthiest Sparkling Water? The Complete Guide to Bubbling Beverages

Sparkling water has shot to the forefront of the health beverage industry over the last few years, marketed as a healthier alternative to soft drinks and a refreshing way to consume the recommended daily water intake. But with an array of options and claims, it can be daunting to choose the true health champion amidst the tempting sea of effervescence.

In this comprehensive exploration, we'll analyze what constitutes ”healthy” when it comes to sparkling water, decipher the labels and roam all the considerations of your next fizzy water fix. 

The Basics of Sparkling Water

At its core, sparkling water is water that has been artificially carbonated. But that fizzy essence is just the beginning; factors such as mineral content, pH balance, and the presence of artificial additives or sweeteners can transform your seemingly simple sip into a beverage with various health implications.

What Do Different Sparkling Water Labels Mean?

Carbonated Water

This term indicates simple tap water that has been carbonated with the addition of carbon dioxide gas. It's the most basic form of sparkling water, and while it's a far better alternative to sugary soft drinks, there are no additional health benefits beyond hydration.

Sparkling Mineral Water

As the name suggests, sparkling mineral spring water is naturally carbonated water that contains minerals like calcium, magnesium, and potassium sourced from underground springs. Again, it's essential to check the label for added sugar or artificial sweeteners, which can negate these benefits.

Flavored Sparkling Water

Flavored sparkling water is exactly what it sounds like - plain carbonated water enhanced with added flavorings. While these options may seem like a healthier alternative to soda, many flavored sparkling waters contain artificial sweeteners or high levels of natural sugars. 

It's essential to check the label for any additives and choose options with minimal added sugars. Not only is GOOD IDEA formulated with amino acids designed to help improve metabolic health, but it’s also naturally flavored with 0 added sugar or artificial sweeteners.

Club Soda

Club soda is similar to carbonated mineral water but has added minerals like potassium bicarbonate and sodium citrate (in contrast to mineral water, club soda doesn't have any naturally occurring minerals). These minerals are what give club soda a slightly salty taste.

tonic water

Tonic Water

Tonic water is carbonated water with added quinine, a bitter compound derived from the cinchona tree. 

Soda Water

Soda water is also similar to carbonated water, but it often has a higher level of carbonation and can have added minerals or flavors. As with other sparkling water options, it's essential to check the label for any added sugars or artificial sweeteners.

The Role of pH in Sparkling Water

The pH of sparkling water can vary. While most have a neutral pH, some flavored options can be slightly acidic, and those with added minerals might be alkaline. Understanding the role of pH, including its impact on dental health and acid reflux, is crucial in making an informed choice.

Kelly A. Reynolds, PhD, the Director of Community, Environment, and Policy for the Exposure Science and Risk Assessment Center (ESRAC) states here there is no scientific evidence that the pH of sparkling water has any bearing on our health.

“Our bodies are designed to handle a wide range of pH values in liquids,” she said. “Orange juice, for example, is acidic with a pH of around 3.5. Our stomach acids have a pH of around 2.0, which is important to maintain digestive health.”

Hidden Dangers in Sugar Substitutes

Many assume that all unsweetened sparkling waters are free from sugars, but this isn't always the case. Some may contain sugar substitutes like aspartame or saccharin, which carry their own set of concerns.

What Are the Dangers of Aspartame or Saccharin?

Aspartame is a low-calorie sweetener that has been linked to various health issues, including headaches, dizziness, and digestive problems. Saccharin also has potential side effects, such as an increased risk of cancer and bladder irritation.

To avoid these risks, choose sparkling water without sugar substitutes or artificial sweeteners, such as GOOD IDEA.

How Much Sugar Should I Consume?

According to Heart & Stroke, less than 5% of calorie intake should come from added sugars. For an average 2,000-calorie diet, 5% is less than 24 grams (or 6 teaspoons).

For context, approximately 10 teaspoons of daily added sugar is contained in one can of pop. Keep this in mind when choosing sparkling water, and be mindful of hidden sugars in flavored options.

Addressing the Myth of Sparkling Water and Bone Health

There's a common misconception that a carbonated drink can leach calcium from bones. We'll dissect this belief and explore the scientific evidence to separate fact from fiction.

Where Did This Myth Originate From?

The myth likely stems from the fact that drinking excessive amounts of soda, which contains high levels of sugar and phosphoric acid, can lead to calcium loss in bones. However, evidence suggests this is not the case for sparkling water.

Healthy Consumption Habits

While sparkling water may not harm your bones, moderation is still crucial if there are added sugars. Consuming large quantities of sugary beverages can have adverse effects on your health.

sparkling water vs plain water

The Lowdown on Hydration: Sparkling Water vs. Plain Water

How does sparkling water stack up against plain water regarding hydration? We'll compare the two and determine if one is superior in terms of quenching your thirst.

Factors Affecting Hydration

Several factors can influence how well your body absorbs and retains water, such as physical activity, climate, and overall health.

Physical Activity

If you're engaging in intense physical activity or sweating excessively, water with added electrolytes is the best choice to replenish lost fluids.


In hot and humid environments, your body may need more water to stay hydrated. In these situations, sparkling water can be a refreshing option without compromising hydration levels.

Health Conditions

Certain health conditions may require specific hydration needs that should be discussed with a healthcare provider. 

Sparkling Water and Digestive Health

For some, sparkling water can be a digestive aid, while for others, it might cause discomfort. We'll investigate the relationship between sparkling water and digestion and guide those with gastrointestinal concerns.

The Gas Factor

The carbonation in some sparkling waters can lead to gas, bloating, and discomfort for some individuals. However, others may find it helpful in promoting digestion. There have been many studies on both effects.

Understanding Your Body's Response

Each person's digestive system is unique, so it's essential to pay attention to how your body responds to sparkling water. If you experience discomfort or bloating after consuming carbonated beverages, it may be best to limit your intake.

Managing Digestive Issues with Sparkling Water

If you experience digestive issues when consuming sparkling water, there are strategies to consider.

You can try:

  • Drinking still or lightly carbonated options instead of highly fizzy ones
  • Avoiding certain foods and drinks that may exacerbate symptoms

Athletes and Active Lifestyles: Sparkling Water as an Exercise Beverage

Is sparkling water an appropriate choice for those with active lifestyles, including athletes? We'll assess the suitability of sparkling water for pre-, during-, and post-workout hydration.

The Electrolyte Equation

For those engaging in strenuous exercise, the inclusion of electrolytes is beneficial. While plain water lacks these minerals, some sparkling water brands offer electrolyte-infused options that can be suitable for athletes.

The "Fizzy" Factor

Carbonation may lead to bloating and discomfort during exercise, making still water a better choice. However, if you enjoy drinking sparkling water as part of your workout routine, opt for lightly carbonated options to reduce the risk of these symptoms.

When Is the Best Time to Consume Sparkling Water?

If you're using sparkling water as an exercise beverage, it's best to consume it after physical activity. This is because the carbonation may cause discomfort during exercise.

Additionally, drinking carbonated water beforehand can cause bloating and hinder performance. During workouts, plain water remains the top choice for optimal hydration.

good idea drinks

Introducing GOOD IDEA: A Lightly Sparkling Water for Better Blood Sugar

GOOD IDEA is a lightly sparkling water brand that contains chromium, five amino acids, potassium, and zinc, which have been shown to have positive effects on blood sugar regulation.

Five essential amino acids and a small amount of the essential mineral chromium (in the form of chromium picolinate) work together to reduce blood sugar. Amino acids (L-Leucine, L-Threonine, L-Lysine Monohydrochloride, L-Isoleucine, L-Valine) prime the metabolism to provide more effective energy from the food you eat.

Chromium picolinate enhances insulin sensitivity to more effectively transport energy into the cells. Combined, they synergistically reduce total blood sugar. This blood sugar stabilization helps to improve our energy levels, reduce cravings, and improve our metabolic health. 

And the things that GOOD IDEA doesn’t include are just as important! With every can of GOOD IDEA, you won’t have to worry about any sugar, artificial sweeteners, or caffeine. Every sip is a keto-friendly, non-GMO delight.

LaCroix, Spindrift, Bubly: The Rise of Sparkling Water Brands

We'll take a closer look at some other sparkling water brands, comparing their unique features and nutritional profiles so you can make an informed choice for yourself:



Some controversy has surrounded LaCroix's use of the term "natural" in its ingredient list. While the brand maintains that all ingredients are natural and free of artificial sweeteners, some consumers dispute this claim.

Nutritional Information

LaCroix has no calories, sugar, or sodium, making it a good choice for those looking to reduce their intake of these nutrients.

Is LaCroix Healthy?

While LaCroix may not have any negative health impacts, it does not offer many nutritional benefits. However, if you enjoy the taste and prefer a healthier alternative to sugary drinks, it can be a suitable option.



Spindrift uses real fruit juice in its sparkling water, but the amount may vary depending on the flavor. Some consumers also note a stronger carbonation level compared to other brands.

Nutritional Information

Spindrifts calorie and sugar content is relatively low, making it a decent option for those looking for a more flavorful alternative to plain water.

Is Spindrift Healthy?

Spindrift may offer some nutritional benefits from the addition of real fruit juice, but it's important to note that the juice they use also adds calories. Make sure to check the label and choose flavors with minimal added sugars.



Bubly uses natural flavors in its sparkling water options. While these ingredients may enhance the taste, they may not be suitable for those with allergies or sensitivities.

Nutritional Information

Bubly has no calories, sugar, or sodium, making it a similar option to LaCroix. However, some consumers have noted that the taste may not be as satisfying as other brands.

Is Bubly Healthy?

Similar to LaCroix, Bubly may not offer many nutritional benefits but can be a better option than other sugary drinks made with high fructose corn syrup.

good idea sparkling water

GOOD IDEA: Lightly Sparkling Water with Added Functionality

As consumers seek out more than just hydration from their beverages, brands like GOOD IDEA have emerged with added functionality. We'll explore the science behind these drinks and their potential health benefits.


Touting a reduced blood sugar response, GOOD IDEA is marketed as more than just lightly sparkling water. We'll examine the research behind its ingredients and potential benefits.


GOOD IDEA contains a blend of minerals and amino acids, along with lightly carbonated water. Its natural flavors offer variety without added sugars or artificial sweeteners.

Nutritional Information

With no calories, no artificial sweeteners, and qualification as a vegan, keto-friendly, and non-GMO drink, GOOD IDEA is a great option for those looking for sparkling water with added functionality. 

More importantly, due to its scientifically crafted blend of amino acids and minerals, GOOD IDEA can be a suitable choice for those looking to manage their blood sugar levels while still enjoying a flavorful beverage.

In one research study with GOOD IDEA, there was a 24% reduction in postprandial blood glucose. In another research study, it was found that a drink containing both 5AA and CrPic (GOOD IDEA’S crafted mix)  lowers postprandial glucose levels in healthy “at-risk” subjects.

Is GOOD IDEA Healthy?

Yes! Scientifically backed and made with natural ingredients, GOOD IDEA is a healthy choice for those looking for added benefits in their sparkling water.

Perrier, San Pellegrino, and Topo Chico: The Classic Sparkling Waters



Perrier contains only carbonated water and natural flavors, making it a suitable option for those looking to avoid added sugars or artificial sweeteners.

Nutritional Information

Perrier has no calories or sugar, but it does have a high mineral content (including sodium) due to its source from natural springs. This may be a disadvantage as the majority of the population consumes too much salt. 

For context, approximately 95 percent of men and 77 percent of women consume more than 2,300 milligrams per day (which is a limit federal health officials recommend).

Is Perrier Healthy?

Perrier contains trace amounts of minerals such as calcium, magnesium, and potassium. Therefore, it can be considered a healthy choice for those looking to stay hydrated without consuming extra calories or sugar.

However, for those looking to lower their salt intake, it’s recommended to regulate your intake levels.

San Pellegrino


San Pellegrino has a variety of beverages that can include carbonated water, flavors, and added sugars. Be sure to check labels for added sugars or artificial sweeteners.

Nutritional Information

Depending on the San Pellegrino option, you can find choices with no calories or options that may be high in sugar (such as their flavored options). 

Again, it’s important to check the label and choose varieties with minimal added sugars. Additionally, similar to Perrier, it may not be suitable for those looking to regulate their salt intake.

Is San Pellegrino Healthy?

Yes and no, depending on the variety. The original sparkling water is a healthy choice, but the fruit-flavored options may provide too much added sugar for some individuals.

Topo Chico


Topo Chico uses carbonated water and natural flavors in their beverages, with some varieties containing added fruit juice or sugar. Be sure to check labels for nutritional information.

Nutritional Information

Topo Chico's classic sparkling water has no calories, sugar, or sodium. However, its flavored options may have added sugars and calories.

Is Topo Chico Healthy?

Like the other classic sparkling waters we've discussed, Topo Chico can be a good alternative healthy choice for those looking to stay hydrated and consume fewer calories. However, with it's sugar-added options, it's important to read labels and choose wisely.

sparkling water alternatives

Adventurous Alternatives: Sparkling Water with a Twist

For those looking for unique and unconventional carbonated waters, we'll examine some options here:

Kombucha Sparkling Water


Kombucha sparkling waters use a base of fermented tea along with carbonated water and natural flavors. Kombucha itself has naturally occurring sugar but always check for any added sugars or artificial sweeteners.

Nutritional Information

Kombucha sparkling waters often have added probiotics, making them a potentially healthier alternative to traditional sugary drinks. However, they may not be suitable for individuals with certain health conditions or those sensitive to fermentation.

Is Kombucha Healthy?

While kombucha might have potential health benefits, it's important to consume it in moderation and be aware of any sugars or artificial sweeteners.

Maple Water Sparkling Water


Maple water sparkling waters use a base of maple water along with carbonated water and natural flavors. Be sure to check labels for added sugars or artificial sweeteners.

Nutritional Information

Compared to sugary drinks, maple water could be considered healthier due to its manganese content and other minerals. However, added sugars or natural sugars from the maple water may still contribute to overall calorie intake.

Is Maple Sparkling Water Healthy?

Choosing maple sparkling waters with low or no added sugar can be a healthier alternative to traditional sodas. Drinking moderation is important with all beverages that contain sugar.

What Is the Healthiest Sparkling Water?

There is no one "healthiest" brand of sparkling water since each brand may offer different health benefits and considerations. It ultimately depends on the individual's unique health situation and preferences.

Instead, it's important to read labels and choose a brand that aligns with your personal health goals and needs. Some brands, such as GOOD IDEA, have functional ingredients that can help you reach certain goals, such as lower blood sugar levels. 

Healthiest Sparkling Water Alternative to Soda

For individuals looking for a healthier alternative to traditional sugary sodas, any sparkling water without added sugars or artificial sweeteners is the best option. Try experimenting with different brands and unique flavors to find the perfect substitute.

good idea helps weightloss

Healthiest Sparkling Water for Weight Loss

Again, GOOD IDEA takes the cake here. Why? Through a science-backed mix of amino acids and minerals, GOOD IDEA works to prime the metabolism by helping to increase insulin sensitivity. Moreover through helping balance blood sugar levels GOOD IDEA reduces cravings and keeps you feeling fuller longer.

Weighing the Pros and Cons

While sparkling water can be a refreshing and healthy alternative to sugary drinks, it's important to consider its individual ingredients and nutritional information. As with any food or beverage, moderation is key to maintaining a balanced diet.

As a whole, here are some general pros and cons of sparkling water:


  • Can serve as a healthy alternative to sugary and calorie-dense beverages
  • Many options are available with various flavors and added nutrients.
  • May provide some health benefits through added minerals and antioxidants


  • Some brands may contain artificial sweeteners or added sugars, so be sure to check labels before purchasing.
  • Certain sparkling waters may have a high sodium content, making them less suitable for individuals with certain health conditions.

The Future of Sparkling Water

Functional Beverages: The Future of Sparkling Water

Sparkling water has been gaining popularity in recent years thanks to its refreshing taste and health-conscious appeal. However, as consumer demand for functional beverages continues to rise, we can expect sparkling water to transform with the addition of functional ingredients.

Functional beverages are drinks that provide specific health benefits beyond hydration. These can include added vitamins, antioxidants, and other ingredients that target specific health concerns. As consumers become more health-conscious and seek out healthier beverage options, the demand for functional beverages is only expected to increase.

And GOOD IDEA sparkling water is ahead of the curve in this trend. With its science-backed formulation containing amino acids and chromium picolinate, it not only provides a refreshing beverage option but also has functional benefits. Studies have shown this mix can help lower blood sugar levels, making GOOD IDEA a great choice for those looking to maintain their blood sugar levels.

In addition to this, GOOD IDEA is a no-sugar option without any artificial flavors. This makes it the perfect choice for those watching their sugar intake without compromising on taste or functionality.


Are all sparkling waters created equal?

No, different brands and varieties of sparkling water may contain varying levels of minerals and natural flavors. It's important to check labels and nutritional information to determine the best option for your health needs.

Can sparkling water replace regular water in my diet?

While sparkling water can contribute to your overall hydration, it should not be seen as a replacement for regular water. The carbonation and minerals in sparkling water may not be suitable for everyone, so it's important to consult with a healthcare professional if you have any concerns.

Are there any potential risks associated with drinking sparkling water?

For most individuals, drinking sparkling water is safe. However, those with certain health conditions, such as acid reflux or irritable bowel syndrome, may experience discomfort from the carbonation. It's best to consult with a healthcare professional if you have any concerns before incorporating sparkling water into your diet.

Can children drink sparkling water?

As with any beverage, moderation is key. In general, sparkling water is safe for children to drink, but parents should monitor their intake and consider any potential risks from carbonation or minerals.

Can sparkling water help with weight loss?

Sparkling waters like GOOD IDEA have no calories (or artificial flavors!), making it a suitable choice for those looking to do weight management and reduce calorie intake. 

does sparkling water have caffeine

Does sparkling water contain caffeine?

Most sparkling water brands do not contain caffeine, but it's important to check labels and ingredients for any caffeine.

How does sparkling water compared to soda?

Sparkling water typically has no added sugar or artificial sweeteners, making it a healthier alternative to soda. However, some may still contain artificial flavors and should be consumed in moderation.

Will drinking sparkling water make me feel bloated?

Some individuals may experience bloating or discomfort from the carbonation in sparkling water. It's best to listen to your body and adjust intake accordingly. Fortunately, GOOD IDEA offers a light carbonated solution, so you don’t have to choose between a potential bloat and refreshing sparkling water.

Can I make my own sparkling water at home?

Yes, there are several devices available for at-home carbonation, allowing you to customize your favorite flavors and control the level of carbonation.

Is sparkling water better for my teeth than soda?

Sparkling water is not as acidic as soda, making it less harmful to tooth enamel. However, some brands may still contain citric acid, which can erode enamel over time.

Can sparkling water help with digestion?

While there is no guarantee, some people may find that the carbonation in sparkling water helps with digestion issues. As always, listen to your body and adjust intake as needed.

How does sparkling water compare to other types of carbonated beverages?

Compared to other carbonated drinks like soda or energy drinks, sparkling water generally is a healthier option. However, watch out for the brands that choose to add extra sugar or artificial sweeteners.

The Verdict: Is Sparkling Water a Healthy For You?

By understanding that ”health” is a multifaceted concept, the answer to this question depends on various factors such as hydration, digestion, and potential health conditions. While it may not be a suitable option for everyone, more often than not, sparkling water can be a healthy beverage choice for many individuals- especially those with added benefits like GOOD IDEA.

Conclusion: Bubble Up with Your Favorite Sparkling Water

Whether you prefer classic mineral water or more adventurous flavors, there's no denying the popularity and versatility of sparkling water. From its humble beginnings to its current reign as a beloved beverage, we've explored the history, ingredients, and potential health benefits of some top brands. Additionally, we've looked at some alternative options for those looking to spice up their sparkling water experience.

With the industry continuously evolving and offering a range of options, there's never been a better time to embrace the more bubbly water side of hydration. So go ahead, crack open your favorite sparkling water, and enjoy its crisp bubbles guilt-free!

Next time you're reaching for a refreshing drink, why not give GOOD IDEA a try? GOOD IDEA will help you harness your natural energy so you can reduce post-meal blood sugar crashes, sugar cravings, and needless calorie intake.

GOOD IDEA helps to provide improved energy levels, enhanced metabolic health, increased mental clarity, and sustainable weight loss! With a range of five lightly sparkling Swedish flavors, from Sea Berry to Swedish Lemon, there's something for everyone.

Shop here!